Helping clients choose the right application path

Some clients were choosing an option that didn’t match their situation before their application had even started. I explored how clearer wording and a different layout could help new and existing clients understand the options and decide how to continue.

Example content for demo purposes only.

Details

Role

Product designer

Team

Product, research, design, content, engineering, and business partners

Timeline

Jan 2025 - May 2025

Status

Live

Summary

Before starting an application, clients were asked one question: “Are you already a CIBC client?” The data showed that some were choosing a path that didn’t match their situation. I looked at how the wording and layout could make that choice clearer.

What I owned

I led the design exploration from understanding the problem to creating the final desktop, tablet, and mobile designs. Along the way, I reviewed other banks’ approaches, mapped the existing journey, and explored three layouts. I worked with designers, UX writers, and engineers to find an approach that supported clients while meeting business, accessibility, and technical needs.

One question, two very different paths

I started by walking through the existing application flow. After choosing a product and selecting “Start your application,” user were asked whether they were already a CIBC client. Their answer determined whether they signed on or continued as a new user.

Two things stood out. The copy explained why signing on was helpful, but not what happened if users chose the other option. The question also assumed existing users could sign on, even though some might not have online banking set up.

What the data showed

Some users were starting on the wrong path

Before the redesign, 40% of new users selected sign-on, while 17% of existing users chose the new-client option. These figures gave me a starting point: look at what might be making the choice unclear before clients moved further into the application.

0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
40%
New users selecting sign-on
17%
Existing users selecting ‘No, continue’
Percentages are calculated within each client group.
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
40%
New users selecting sign-on
17%
Existing users selecting ‘No, continue’
Percentages are calculated within each client group.

Learning from other banks

I looked at how other Canadian banks presented the same choice. I wanted to understand how they explained the benefit of signing on, separated the two paths, and helped clients know what to expect next.

TD Bank: Give each path its own space

TD separates the two paths into clear sections, each with its own explanation and button.

Scotiabank: Shows why signing in helps

Scotiabank puts the benefit right in the sign-in button, explaining that signing in can make the application faster.

RBC: Make the next step clear

RBC clearly names the new user option, rather than asking people to guess what “continue” means.

Turning patterns into design directions

I explored three ways to arrange the options. Each used a different layout to connect the explanations and buttons, with the goal of making both paths easy to understand without adding too much to read.

Compare both paths at a glance

I placed the options next to each other, keeping each explanation close to its button. The aim was to make both paths easy to compare within a compact modal.

Click to expand

Compare both paths at a glance

I placed the options next to each other, keeping each explanation close to its button. The aim was to make both paths easy to compare within a compact modal.

Click to expand

Compare both paths at a glance

I placed the options next to each other, keeping each explanation close to its button. The aim was to make both paths easy to compare within a compact modal.

Click to expand

Refining the direction together

I reviewed the three options with other designers, UX writers, and product engineers. I recommended the stacked layout because it kept each explanation close to its button.

We discussed how the layouts would handle longer copy and smaller screens, and whether the button labels made sense without clients reading every description. As a team, we agreed to move forward with Option 2.

Option 1

Side-by-Side

PROS

Equal hierarchy: Shows both paths side-by-side.

Clear separation: Easy to scan at a glance.

Low dev effort: Uses existing modal pattern.

CONS

Cramped columns: Breaks easily with longer translated copy.

Guideline gap: Does not meet brand standards.

Option 2

Selected direction

PROS

Responsive ready: Stacked layout adapts cleanly to any screen.

Logical pairing: Keeps explanation and CTA grouped together.

CONS

Visual weight: Top primary CTA may overshadow new client path.

Option 3

Split Footer

PROS

Generous width: Gives explanations full horizontal breathing room.

Clean layout: Separates reading copy from action buttons.

CONS

Disconnected flow: Separates actions from their explanations.

Order mismatch: Left-to-right buttons conflict with top-to-bottom copy.

The direction I chose

I chose the stacked layout to keep each explanation directly above its button, giving each path its own space. While the side-by-side option worked on desktop, it needed to stack on tablet and mobile anyway. Using that structure throughout kept the experience consistent across screen sizes.

Outcome

The redesigned modal launched on June 2025. Post-launch reporting showed that new clients selecting sign-on fell from 40% to 12.6%, while existing clients selecting the new-client route fell from 17% to 5.5%. These were encouraging changes, though the reporting didn’t show a clear link to more completed applications.

Reflection

This project reinforced how much the order and placement of content matter, especially when users skim. Working cross-functionally helped me look beyond the wording and consider how the explanations and layout worked together to make each choice clear.

If resources allow, I’d also explore how existing clients without online banking understand the options. Being a CIBC client doesn’t always mean being ready to sign on.

a man smiling for the camera

Michelle Lee

Product Designer ⌄

6:53 AM

Loading weather data...

Open to roles